blog | cv | | uws fact | ieet | selt | gsp | hca | C@tO | HF posthumanism | bioethics port | | GMA the medicalization of cyberspace
www.flickr.com
This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from andymiah. Make your own badge here.

contact
School of Media
Language & Music
University of the
West of Scotland

Ayr Campus
KA8 OSR
Scotland, UK

email@andymiah.net

t: +44 (0) 7962 716 616
f: +44 (0) 1292 886 371

 

 

Society for Applied Philosophy

 

 


The Patenting Of Human DNA

Paper given at Are Genes Us?, The Annual Conference of the Society for Applied Philosophy, May 2000

 

This presentation led to the following publication:

Miah, A. (2003) Patenting Human DNA, in B. Almond and M. Parker (Eds)
Ethical Issues in the New Genetics: Are genes us?, Aldershot, Ashgate, pp.111-117
.

 

.

The recent activities of the American company, Celera Genomics, to obtain patent rights on aspects of the human genome brings into focus whether life, indeed human life, should belong to anyone or anybody. The question of DNA ownership has not been neglected within bioethics and biolaw. Central to these concerns are the implications such patenting has for the development of scientific research and the, supposedly, vulgar franchising (and likely exploitation) of human body parts. However, it remains unclear to what degree the patenting of DNA does actually count as owning life. Furthermore, it begs the question as to what is the moral significance of owning such material and to what degree one’s identity is comprised by one’s genetic heritage. That a blueprint of the human genome could tell us anything about a particular individual does not seem, necessarily, problematic. Yet, how such information is used and made available to interested parties does have implications that are morally questionable. Ought, for example, the owners of particular aspects of the human genome, be entitled to sell this to research companies seeking such noble ambitions as vaccines for diseases? Of course, integral to the distaste about patenting life, is the prospect of trading human life – the vulgarity of combining money and human dignity. Evidence of such dislike has appeared most recently from the emergence of the ronsangels.com website, a company set up for the auctioning of eggs belonging to female models (starting bids between $15,000 and 150,000 U.S. dollars). Though limited in choice of stock, this pioneering genetic supermarket argues that it is simply seeking to promote choice, providing the opportunity to purchase the contemporary social asset of beauty (and, more legitimately, health). From here, one begins to recognise the manufactured future of the human species, with the next line of products being the genes of athletes or professors (recent news headlines reveal infertility couples seeking the eggs of Oxbridge students). Condemned by infertility groups world wide, of all the applications of genetic technologies, this practice seems unequivocally repulsive for the simple reason that it has the effect of enforcing the values of one generation onto another, thus stalling social change. From a legal position, whether the human genome should belong to anyone requires one to take a position on whether new life is seen as invention or discovery. However, whether the patenting of life is actually perceived as compromising one’s personal identity is a very different question requiring a quite different perspective. That human DNA might belong to a company within the United States, or to anyone for that matter, seems acceptable, though does not mean allowing organisations to propagate this ownership to do as they wish with these findings and monopolise this knowledge. Neither does owing the patent to human DNA mean that any individual is owned by another.

 

     
 

resarch interests

art&design // bioethics // china // cyberculture // ethics // law // medicine // olympics // outer space // politics // public engagement with science // science // sport // technology

just published

Miah, A. (2008, Oct) 17 Days in Beiing, Centre for Olympic Studies, Barcelona.

Miah, A. (2008, Aug 3) Enhance Athletes: It's Only Natural, Washington Post.

Miah, A. (2008, July 31) Inside the Mind of a Marathon man, Nature, 454, 583-4.

Miah, A. (2008) Paralympics 2.0, Bioethics Forum, The Hastings Center.

Miah, A. (2008) Letter to Utopia: A Reply to Bostrom, Studies in Ethics, Law and Technology, 2(1).

Miah, A. (2008) Engineering Greater Resilience or Radical Transhuman Enhancement, Studies in Ethics, Law and Technology, 2(1).

my next event

Liverpool, UK i (30 Oct, 2008)
Book launch: Human Futures, and BBC Radio 3 Free Thinking Festival.

London, UK i (14 Oct, 2008)
BioCentre 2008 series: "People Power for the Third Millennium: Technology, Democracy and Human Rights, Symposoium on "Arts and Technology: the role of the arts in democratic policy making".

Glasgow, Scotland i (30 Sept, 2008)
Our Cultural & Moral Commitment to Discover, Create, and Support New Life Forms, for LESS REMOTE: The Futures of Space Exploration: an Arts & Humanities Symposium, International Astronautical Congress, SEC, Glasgow, Scotland [abstract]

in press

Miah, A. (2008) Human Futures: Art in an Age of Uncertainty, FACT & Liverpool University Press.

Miah, A. (2008) Justifying Human Enhancement: The Accumulation of Biocultural Capital. In: Wint, S. Ethical Futures. The Royal Society for the Encouragement of the Arts (RSA), London.

Miah, A. (2008) Playing Games with Artificial Intelligence. Hale, B. (Ed) Philosophy Looks at Chess . Open Court Press.

Miah, A. (2008). Posthumanism: A Critical History. In Gordijn, B. & Chadwick, R. 'Medical Enhancements and Posthumanity. Springer.

Miah, A. (2008) 'Blessed are the Forgetful': The Ethics of Memory Modification in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. In Shapshay, S. (Ed) Bioethics Through Film, Johns Hopkins University Press.

 

just published

Stein, D.J. (2008) Philosophy of Psychopharmacology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, p.118.

More, P. (2008) Enhancing Me: The Hope and the Hype of Human Enhancement. John Wiley & Sons, p.249.

Christian Lenk, Nils Hoppe & Roberto Andorno (2007) Ethics and Law of Intellectual Property: Current Problems in Politics, Science and Technology (Applied Legal Philosophy), Ashgate, p.84.

Zwart, N. H. (2007). "Genomics and self-knowledge: implications for societal research and debate." New Genetics and Society 26(2): 181-202.

Mitchell, C. B., E. D. Pellegrino, et al. (2007). Biotechnology and the Human Good. Washington, DC., Georgetown University Press.

Peters, H. P., J. T. Lang, et al. (2007). "Culture and Technological Innovation: Impact of Institutional Trust and Appreciation of Nature on Attitudes towards Food Biotechnology in the USA and Germany." International Journal of Public Opinion Research 19(2): 191-220.

House of Commons Select Committee, Science And Technology (2007) Report on Human Enhancement Technologies in Sport.

Koolstra CM, Bos MJW, Vermeulen IE. Through which medium should science information professionals communicate with the public: television or the internet? Journal of Science Communication 2006;5(3):1-8.

   

interviews

Oct, 2008
The Independent, Visionaries feature

Aug, 2008
ITN News,
The Telegraph,
Evening Standard,
Washington Post,

May, 2008
The technological enhancement of man, Danish Broadcasting Corporation

April, 2008
Evening Standard
Beijing 2008 Olympics and Protest

March, 2008
The Sports Factor, ABC Radio, Blogging at the Beijing Olympics

Feb, 2008
ESPN Magazine.

flashback

 

recent places
         
London, UK i (14 Oct, 2008)
BioCentre 2008 series: "People Power for the Third Millennium: Technology, Democracy and Human Rights, Symposoium on "Arts and Technology: the role of the arts in democratic policy making".
  Glasgow, Scotland i (30 Sept, 2008)
Our Cultural & Moral Commitment to Discover, Create, and Support New Life Forms, for LESS REMOTE: The Futures of Space Exploration: an Arts & Humanities Symposium, International Astronautical Congress, SEC, Glasgow, Scotland [abstract]
  Oxford, Scotland i (29 Sept, 2008)
Workshop on Innovative Media for the Digital Economy, Oxford E-Research Centre, Oxford University
         
Beijing, China c (5 Aug, 2008)
Chair and Speaker for panel symposium on Emergent Journalistic Cultures at the Olympics [outline]
  Olympia, Greece i (20 July, 2008)
Supervising Professor, International Olympic Acadmy 16th Postgraduate Seminar [Lecture Outlines].
  Leeds, UK c (16 July, 2008)
Ambush Media: Journalistic Freedom & Media Politics at the Beijing Olympics, Olympic Politics and Protest, Leeds Metropolitan University [abstract].
         
London, UK ia (4 July, 2008)
Research Cluster on Innovative Media for a Digital Economy: Health Industries Workshop, British Medical Association House.
  Liverpool, UK i (July, 2008)
Keynote, Body & Economy, London 2012 Cultural Olympiad, FACT.
  Chicago , USA ia (Jun, 2008)
2016 Olympic Bid conference, the contribution of the arts.
 
del.icio.us tags