| |

Engineering athleticism: The epistemological basis of
enhancement
Between
a Rock and a Hard Place, St Martin's College, Lancaster,
UK
.
|
 |
The
possibilities for using human gene therapy are regarded
as morally questionable, amongst other reasons, for their
likely yielding to a more frivolous use of such technology
for genetic enhancement. Questioning the fictionality of,
so-called, designer genes seems increasingly redundant with
the proliferation of new technologies and new possibilities.
Yet, such prospects of enhancement raises the question of
what kinds of enhancements are worthwhile to pursue. Furthermore,
it must be asked to what degree genetic enhancement does
actually impact upon human lives and whether it is so great
that resources should be spent on developing such technologies.
Within competitive sport, the advantage of being able to
genetically enhance oneself are obvious. To put oneself
at an advantage is regarded as fundamental to the activity,
providing it is within the permissible means of the sport.
However, to utilise such technology admits that within
sport it is the result that matters. This overwhelming
principle does seem reflective of current practice and is,
undoubtedly, cloaked in the commercialisation of sport.
Yet, the paramounce of results in sport has not always been
so clear. Within even some non-western sport, the emphasis
on winning is secondary to the ritual and spectacle of the
event. Furthermore, not earning one’s advantage within sport
as would be the case for the engineered athlete is contrary
to current sports ethics, the doping issue most notable.
As such, the use of genetics to promote a more capable athlete
can be argued as missing the more important values of competition,
the mutual quest, and the striving for excellence. Perhaps
more reprehensible is that, to engineer a child with a particular
characteristic can be argued as enacting a form of eugenics.
Whilst such eugenics might be deemed morally sound since
they are about a personal choice rather than a social programme
of engineering, such choice does compromise the re-evaluation
of sport as a performance. If we use genetics to enhance
our babies, we will no longer have the option to return
to a more humanitarian philosophy whereby the performance
might be deemed less important to, say, the mutual endeavour.
By considering the effect of genetically enhancing persons
for sport, one can also recognise that engineered persons
must fit within environments where genes do matter. In specific
contexts of human enterprise, our genes play a greater and
lesser role in our achievements. This does not render one
committed to genetic essentialism or, for that matter, populist
hysteria about what genetic engineering can do perfect
people, designer genes, superman and wonderwoman and so
on. The elite athlete is a composition of training, genetics,
and many other factors, and without either of these characteristics,
the athlete would not be elite. Rather, it is to acknowledge
that the motivation for enhancing one’s child is entirely
rational and, providing such technologies are safe, would
contribute to the flourishing of an individual without any
necessary threat to one’s identity. Thus, the significant
question becomes, not whether we are our genes, but whether
our genes are at all influential in determining our lived
experience. Within elite sport, this is most certainly the
case. .
|
| |
|
|
|
|
art&design // bioethics // china // cyberculture // ethics // law // medicine // olympics // outer space // politics // public engagement with science // science // sport // technology

Miah, A. (2008) Human Futures: Art in an Age of Uncertainty, FACT & Liverpool University Press.
Miah, A. (2008) A Deep Blue Grasshopper: Playing Games with Artificial Intelligence. Hale, B. (Ed) Philosophy Looks at Chess. Open Court Press, 13-23.
Miah, A. (2008). Posthumanism: A Critical History. In Gordijn, B. & Chadwick, R. 'Medical Enhancements and Posthumanity. Springer.
Miah, A. (2008, Oct) 17 Days in Beiing, Centre for Olympic Studies, Barcelona.
Miah, A. (2008, Aug 3) Enhance Athletes: It's Only Natural, Washington Post.
Miah, A. (2008, July 31) Inside the Mind of a Marathon man, Nature, 454, 583-4.
Miah, A. (2008) Paralympics 2.0, Bioethics Forum, The Hastings Center.
Miah, A. (2008) Letter to Utopia: A Reply to Bostrom, Studies in Ethics, Law and Technology, 2(1).
Miah, A. (2008) Engineering Greater Resilience or Radical Transhuman Enhancement, Studies in Ethics, Law and Technology, 2(1).

Washington, DC, USA i (Dec, 2008)
Genetic enhancement conference, American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research.
London, UK i (November, 2008)
Human Body Enhancement, panel debate, Words on Monday, Nature and Kings Place Music Foundatio.
|

Miah, A. (2009) Justifying Human Enhancement: The Accumulation of Biocultural Capital. In: Wint, S. Ethical Futures. The Royal Society for the Encouragement of the Arts (RSA), London.
Miah, A. (2009) 'Blessed are the Forgetful': The Ethics of Memory Modification in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. In Shapshay, S. (Ed) Bioethics Through Film, Johns Hopkins University Press.
|

Stein, D.J. (2008) Philosophy of Psychopharmacology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, p.118.
More, P. (2008) Enhancing Me: The Hope and the Hype of Human Enhancement. John Wiley & Sons, p.249.
Christian Lenk, Nils Hoppe & Roberto Andorno (2007) Ethics and Law of Intellectual Property: Current Problems in Politics, Science and Technology (Applied Legal Philosophy), Ashgate, p.84.
Zwart, N. H. (2007). "Genomics and self-knowledge: implications for societal research and debate." New Genetics and Society 26(2): 181-202.
Mitchell, C. B., E. D. Pellegrino, et al. (2007). Biotechnology and the Human Good. Washington, DC., Georgetown University Press.
Dec, 2008
BBC Radio 4,
Start the Week with Andrew Marr
Nov, 2008
The Scotsman (2-page profile)
Nov, 2008
The Independent on Sunday,
feature on Celebrity Culture
Oct, 2008
The Independent, Visionaries feature
Aug, 2008
ITN News,
The Telegraph,
Evening Standard,
Washington Post,
|

| |
|
|
|
|
Edinburgh, UK i (November, 2008)
Sport Law Conference, Edinburgh University Law School . |
|
Liverpool, UK ia (15 Oct, 2008)
Book Preview: Human Futures, and BBC Radio 3 Free Thinking Festival |
|
Florence, Italy i (25 Oct, 2008)
Genetic Enhancement via Genetic Selection: Bioethical and Biolegal Boundaries, Gene Doping International Symposium. |
| |
|
|
|
|
London, UK i (14 Oct, 2008)
BioCentre 2008 series: "People Power for the Third Millennium: Technology, Democracy and Human Rights, Symposoium on "Arts and Technology: the role of the arts in democratic policy making". |
|
Glasgow, Scotland i (30 Sept, 2008)
Our Cultural & Moral Commitment to Discover, Create, and Support New Life Forms, for LESS REMOTE: The Futures of Space Exploration: an Arts & Humanities Symposium, International Astronautical Congress, SEC, Glasgow, Scotland [abstract] |
|
Oxford, Scotland i (29 Sept, 2008)
Workshop on Innovative Media for the Digital Economy, Oxford E-Research Centre, Oxford University |
| |
|
|
|
|
Beijing, China c (5 Aug, 2008)
Chair and Speaker for panel symposium on Emergent Journalistic Cultures at the Olympics [outline] |
|
Olympia, Greece i (20 July, 2008)
Supervising Professor, International Olympic Acadmy 16th Postgraduate Seminar [Lecture Outlines]. |
|
Leeds, UK c (16 July, 2008)
Ambush Media: Journalistic Freedom & Media Politics at the Beijing Olympics, Olympic Politics and Protest, Leeds Metropolitan University [abstract]. |
| |
 |
| |
| |
|